Our Team

Meet your local insurance experts.

Outstanding service starts with an outstanding team. Meet the professionals behind Mathias Insurance.


Kevin Mathias

Photo of Kevin

  • business owner Mathias Insurance, self-employed, Independent Insurance Agent since 1980
  • married for 46 years- five grandsons- Loved by Lola
  • 30 year Yuma Lighthouse Advisor
  • native Coloradan born in Del Norte, CO- grew up in Denver, CO, went to Adams State College
  • member of Washington Yuma Gideon Camp
  • member Yuma Lions Club
  • Favorites- Mexican food-spicy salsa, music lover-tenor, Contemporary Christian, Classical, Bagpipes-Black watch and guitar player.

Sarah Gardner

Photo of Sarah

  • Coloradan – born in Wray, Colorado
  • office manager/secretary for Mathias Insurance sense October 20, 2017 currently working on my insurance license
  • married 13 years with 3 daughters
  • favorites – hunting, family time, making memories, scrapbooking, being creative and crafty and love pizza.

Need an insurance quote? Get in touch!

Access quotes from Colorado's most trusted insurance carriers. It’s comparison shopping at the click of a mouse.

Request a Quote 970-848-3170